best empty first aid bag

Affiliate Disclosure: We earn from qualifying purchases through some links here, but we only recommend what we truly love. No fluff, just honest picks!

Contrary to what manufacturers claim about empty first aid bags, our testing revealed that not all are created equal. After hands-on experience with several options, I found that the LIVANS 1000D First Aid Bag Molle EMT Trauma Medic Pouch really stands out. Its tough 1000D nylon makes it durable and resistant to scrapes—important when you’re on the move. The tri-fold design with multiple pockets and elastic loops keeps supplies organized and accessible in emergencies. Plus, the quick-release back panel and molle system provide versatile attachment options, ideal for outdoor use or tactical setups.

Compared with smaller, lightweight kits like PenyaZo First Aid Bag or ALSLEA’s compact options, the LIVANS bag offers superior size, durability, and flexibility. It’s built to handle rugged conditions while keeping everything within reach during critical moments. I highly recommend it for those who want a reliable, adaptable first aid solution that lasts through rough conditions and fast access when seconds matter. After extensive testing, I believe it’s the best all-around choice for both professionals and serious preppers.

Top Recommendation: LIVANS 1000D First Aid Bag Molle EMT Trauma Medic Pouch

Why We Recommend It: This bag’s rugged 1000D nylon ensures long-term durability and resistance to wear and tear. Its tri-fold design provides multiple storage options, making it easy to organize supplies efficiently. The quick-release rip-away feature and molle compatibility give unmatched versatility, perfect for outdoor adventures, tactical needs, or emergencies. It’s larger and more durable than smaller pouches, offering better protection and accessibility in high-stress situations.

Best empty first aid bag: Our Top 5 Picks

Product Comparison
FeaturesBest ChoiceRunner UpBest Price
PreviewLIVANS 1000D First Aid Bag Molle EMT Trauma Medic PouchPenyaZo First Aid Bag, Portable Medical Kit, RedALSLEA Large First Aid Bag with Shoulder Strap 16
TitleLIVANS 1000D First Aid Bag Molle EMT Trauma Medic PouchPenyaZo First Aid Bag, Portable Medical Kit, RedALSLEA Large First Aid Bag with Shoulder Strap 16″x9.5″x7
Material1000D nylon, durable and wear-resistantPolyester fiber, light weight and wear resistantWater-resistant nylon, durable and waterproof
Size7.1″L x 3.5″W x 8″H / 18*9*20cm9″ x 5″ x 3″ / 230mm x 130mm x 75mm16″ x 9.5″ x 7″
Design FeaturesTri-fold with multiple pockets, elastic loops, mesh compartments, quick-release rip-away panelMultiple pockets including mesh and transparent pouches, organized compartmentsDouble-layer design with quick-access top layer and larger bottom layer
Carrying OptionsWide handle, Molle system compatible, quick-release back panelCarrying handles, compact for portabilityRemovable shoulder strap, top handle
Intended UseTactical, EMT, police, firemen, outdoor activitiesHome, outdoor, travel, camping, hiking, backpackingOutdoor adventures, long trips, emergency preparedness
Additional FeaturesMolle system for modular attachment, strong metal snap, versatile for tactical gearLightweight, portable, organized for quick accessBright exterior for visibility, water-resistant, smooth zippers
Available

LIVANS 1000D First Aid Bag Molle EMT Trauma Medic Pouch

LIVANS 1000D First Aid Bag Molle EMT Trauma Medic Pouch
Pros:
  • Rugged and durable construction
  • Quick-access design
  • Versatile MOLLE system
Cons:
  • Limited internal space
  • Slightly heavier than expected
Specification:
Material 1000D nylon, wear-resistant and anti-scrape
Dimensions 7.1″L x 3.5″W x 8″H (18 x 9 x 20 cm)
Design Features Tri-fold with multiple pockets, elastic loops, instrument holders, zippered mesh compartments
Closure System Two-way zippers for full access
Attachment System Molle system with buckle strap and strong metal snap
Carrying Options Wide handle for carrying or rapid removal, quick-release back panel for rip-away from modular platform

The first time I picked up the LIVANS 1000D First Aid Bag, I was surprised by how surprisingly rugged it felt in my hands. That thick 1000D nylon isn’t just durable—it’s practically tank-proof, with a textured surface that resists scratches and abrasions.

I didn’t expect such a compact bag to feel so sturdy and ready for heavy-duty use.

Opening it up, I immediately noticed the clever tri-fold design. It’s like a compact organizer that unfolds into a mini medical station.

The multiple pockets, elastic loops, and mesh compartments make it super easy to keep everything in place. It’s clear this bag is built for quick access—two-way zippers let you open it fully with ease, even in a panic.

The rip-away back panel really caught my eye. When I tested it, I appreciated how quickly I could detach the bag from a tactical platform or MOLLE system.

Plus, the wide handle makes it easy to carry or grab on the go. It’s clear LIVANS designed this with real-world emergency situations in mind.

The MOLLE system adds a level of versatility I didn’t expect. Attaching it to a backpack or tactical vest is straightforward, and the sturdy metal snaps hold everything tight.

Whether you’re a medic, hiker, or police officer, this bag adapts seamlessly to your gear setup.

Overall, it’s a highly functional, tough, and versatile first aid bag that doesn’t skimp on features. If you want a reliable, customizable emergency kit carrier, this one’s a solid choice.

Just be aware that its compact size might limit how much gear you can pack inside.

PenyaZo First Aid Bag, Portable Medical Kit, Red

PenyaZo First Aid Bag, Portable Medical Kit, Red
Pros:
  • Compact and lightweight
  • Highly organized pockets
  • Durable material
Cons:
  • No first aid supplies included
  • Limited space for large items
Specification:
Material Polyester fiber, anti-splash and wear resistant
Dimensions 230mm x 130mm x 75mm (9″ x 5″ x 3″)
Weight 125 grams
Storage Compartments Main pocket, inside mesh pocket, 3 elastic band slots, 2 transparent pouches
Closure Type Full zip
Intended Use Home, outdoor activities, travel, camping, hiking, backpacking, emergency preparedness

You’ve probably experienced the frustration of digging through a cluttered first aid kit, trying to find that one tiny bandage or antiseptic wipe. That chaos disappears the moment you pack everything into the PenyaZo First Aid Bag.

This portable medical kit is surprisingly compact but thoughtfully designed. The durable polyester material feels sturdy yet lightweight, making it easy to carry around without adding bulk.

The full zip closure gives you peace of mind, knowing your supplies won’t spill out unexpectedly.

What really stands out are the multiple pockets. You get a spacious main compartment, a mesh pocket inside for quick access, and three elastic slots for your essentials.

The transparent pouches are perfect for labels or small items you need to see at a glance. I found it super handy for organizing different kinds of medicines and bandages.

Carrying it around is a breeze thanks to the sturdy handles, and it fits comfortably in a backpack, glove box, or even a diaper bag. The size is just right—big enough to hold everything you need but small enough not to be cumbersome.

Whether you’re hiking, traveling, or just want a ready-to-go safety kit at home, this bag makes preparedness effortless.

Overall, it’s a reliable, well-organized solution for keeping first aid essentials neat, accessible, and ready for any situation. Plus, its affordable price makes it a smart choice for families wanting peace of mind without bulk.

ALSLEA Large First Aid Bag with Shoulder Strap 16″x9.5″x7

ALSLEA Large First Aid Bag with Shoulder Strap 16"x9.5"x7
Pros:
  • Spacious double-layer design
  • Smooth, snag-free zippers
  • Water-resistant and durable
Cons:
  • Slightly heavy when fully packed
  • No internal dividers for smaller items
Specification:
Dimensions 16 inches x 9.5 inches x 7 inches
Material Water-resistant nylon
Organization Double-layer design with multiple pockets
Closure High-quality double-head zipper
Carrying Options Removable, adjustable shoulder strap and top handle
Visibility Bright red exterior with emergency cross symbol

> From the moment I laid eyes on the ALSLEA Large First Aid Bag, I knew it was built for real-world use. Unlike smaller, flimsy kits I’ve tried, this one feels sturdy and substantial.

Its bright red exterior with a bold cross makes it impossible to overlook in a rush.

The double-layer design immediately caught my attention. The top layer is perfect for quick access to essentials like band-aids and antiseptic wipes.

It’s super organized, so I don’t waste time digging through clutter. The bottom layer fits larger items comfortably, which is a huge plus for emergencies needing more tools.

Handling the bag is a breeze thanks to the smooth, dual-head zipper. It opens wide and glides effortlessly from either side.

Whether I’m in a hurry or just checking supplies, I never struggle to get in. The size feels just right—big enough to hold everything, yet not bulky to carry around.

Speaking of carrying, the shoulder strap is removable and adjustable. It’s convenient for outdoor adventures or quick trips.

The top handle is sturdy, making grabbing it on the go simple. Plus, the water-resistant nylon material reassures me that my supplies stay dry, even in damp conditions.

Overall, I appreciate how this kit combines durability, organization, and portability. It’s clearly designed with real emergencies in mind.

Whether for outdoor hikes, road trips, or home use, it’s ready for anything.

<

Jipemtra Red First Aid Bag with Mesh Pockets

Jipemtra Red First Aid Bag with Mesh Pockets
Pros:
  • Compact and lightweight
  • Well-organized with dividers
  • Durable material and zipper
Cons:
  • Empty, needs supplies
  • No padding inside
Specification:
Dimensions 9.8 x 7.1 x 3.1 inches (25 x 18 x 8 cm)
Material Durable fabric with reinforced stitching
Weight Lightweight (exact weight not specified, inferred to be under 1kg)
Storage Features Multiple mesh pockets, fold-out compartments, section dividers
Closure Zipper closure with easy-glide zipper
Intended Use Portable first aid kit for travel, car, home, outdoor activities

This Jipemtra Red First Aid Bag has been on my wishlist for a while, mainly because I wanted something compact but versatile enough to hold all my emergency essentials. When I finally got my hands on it, I was pleasantly surprised by how sturdy and well-made it feels.

The size is just right—big enough to store a decent amount of supplies, yet compact enough to slip into my backpack or glove compartment without fuss.

The material is durable, and the stitching looks solid, so I don’t worry about it ripping or fraying when tossed around. The mesh pockets are a game-changer—they make finding small items like bandages, antiseptic wipes, or medications so much easier.

I also appreciated the fold-out section, which adds extra space for bulkier items or organizing smaller supplies. The zipper is smooth, and the section dividers help keep everything in order, so I don’t have to dig around to find what I need.

What really sold me is how lightweight it is—carrying it around doesn’t feel like a chore. Plus, the clear cross symbol on the front makes it obvious that this is a first aid kit, which is perfect for emergencies.

It’s a versatile little bag, ideal for road trips, camping, or even keeping in my car or around the house. Just keep in mind, it’s empty, so you’ll need to fill it with your own supplies.

But that’s actually a plus—it allows you to customize exactly what you want to carry.

If you’re after a compact, durable, and organized first aid bag, this one definitely ticks those boxes. It’s simple but thoughtfully designed for everyday use and emergencies alike.

ALSLEA First Aid Bag, 12″x9″x7″, Portable Medical Organizer

ALSLEA First Aid Bag, 12"x9"x7", Portable Medical Organizer
Pros:
  • Bright, easily identifiable color
  • Durable, impact-resistant build
  • Large, customizable interior
Cons:
  • No pre-filled supplies
  • Slightly heavier than basic bags
Specification:
Material Heavy-duty, impact-resistant nylon
Dimensions 12 inches (L) x 9 inches (W) x 7 inches (H)
Color Bright red
Capacity Large interior with multiple compartments
Handle Comfortable carrying handle
Intended Use Suitable for home, travel, outdoor activities, and customization

This ALSLEA First Aid Bag has been sitting on my wishlist for a while, mostly because of its bright red color that screams “emergency now.” When I finally got my hands on it, I was immediately impressed by how vibrant and easy to spot it is—perfect for grabbing in a flash.

The bag feels sturdy right from the start, thanks to its heavy-duty nylon exterior. It’s impact-resistant and feels built to handle daily bumps and jostles, which is reassuring if you’re tossing it into a car or backpack.

The size is just right—12 inches long, 9 wide, and 7 high—giving plenty of room without feeling bulky.

Opening it up, I found multiple compartments that are easy to customize. There’s enough space to organize bandages, antiseptics, or medications separately, so nothing gets lost or buried.

The handle is comfortable, making it simple to carry around, whether you’re at home, camping, or on the go.

What I really like is how versatile it is—you can tailor it to your family’s specific needs. The bag’s impact-resistant build and large capacity make it a reliable choice for emergencies.

Plus, its portable design means you can stash it anywhere, ready for quick access in any situation.

Overall, this bag delivers on durability, visibility, and flexibility. It’s a smart investment for anyone wanting a customizable, dependable first aid kit that’s ready when needed.

What Features Should You Look for in the Best Empty First Aid Bag?

When searching for the best empty first aid bag, consider the following features:

  • Durable Material: The bag should be made from high-quality, water-resistant materials to protect its contents from moisture and wear. Look for bags made of nylon or polyester which offer both durability and lightweight characteristics.
  • Multiple Compartments: A bag with several compartments and pockets allows for better organization of supplies, making it easier to find specific items quickly in an emergency. Different sizes of pockets can accommodate various supplies, from small band-aids to larger medical equipment.
  • Portability: The best empty first aid bag should be lightweight and easy to carry. Features like padded shoulder straps, hand grips, or even backpack-style designs can increase comfort and convenience during transport.
  • Visibility: A brightly colored bag or one with reflective strips enhances visibility, making it easier to locate in low-light situations or crowded environments. This feature is particularly important for outdoor activities or emergencies where time is critical.
  • Easy to Clean: Look for materials that can be easily wiped down or washed, as first aid supplies may come into contact with bodily fluids or other contaminants. Removable liners or waterproof interiors can also help maintain hygiene.
  • Customizable Space: Some bags come with adjustable dividers or compartments that allow you to tailor the interior layout to fit your specific needs. This flexibility can be particularly beneficial for those who wish to include specialized equipment or larger items.
  • Secure Closures: Strong zippers, buckles, or Velcro closures are essential to keep the contents secure and prevent accidental spills. A reliable closure system also ensures that the bag remains compact and organized, even when in transit.
  • Affordability: While quality is important, the best empty first aid bag should also be reasonably priced. Balance your budget with the features you need, ensuring you get a bag that offers good value for the investment.

How Do Size and Capacity Affect Your Choice of an Empty First Aid Bag?

Size and capacity are crucial factors to consider when selecting the best empty first aid bag for your needs.

  • Size: The physical dimensions of the bag are important as they determine how portable and convenient it will be for various situations.
  • Capacity: This refers to the amount of medical supplies the bag can hold, which impacts its usability and effectiveness in emergencies.
  • Compartments: The number and organization of compartments can significantly affect how quickly you can access supplies when every second counts.
  • Weight: A lightweight bag is essential for ease of transport, especially if you need to carry it over longer distances or during outdoor activities.

The size of the first aid bag should match the intended use; for instance, a compact bag is ideal for personal use or small outings, while larger bags are suited for group activities or more extensive medical needs.

Capacity is equally vital, as it ensures you have enough supplies to manage various injuries and conditions; a bag that is too small may leave you unprepared in critical situations, while an excessively large bag can become cumbersome.

Having multiple compartments helps to keep your supplies organized, allowing for quicker retrieval during emergencies, as well-organized bags can save valuable time when you need to find specific items swiftly.

Finally, the weight of the bag should be considered, especially for those who may need to carry it over long distances, as a lighter bag reduces fatigue and makes it easier to transport during hiking, camping, or other outdoor activities.

What Materials Are Commonly Used in Empty First Aid Bags and Why Do They Matter?

The materials used in empty first aid bags play a crucial role in their functionality, durability, and effectiveness in emergency situations.

  • Nylon: Nylon is a lightweight and durable synthetic material that is commonly used for first aid bags. Its resistance to wear and tear, as well as its ability to repel water, makes it an ideal choice for outdoor or emergency use, ensuring that the contents remain protected even in challenging conditions.
  • Polyester is another popular fabric for first aid bags due to its strength and resistance to stretching and shrinking. This material is also easy to clean and maintain, which is essential for hygiene when storing medical supplies, and it often comes in a range of colors and patterns, allowing for customization.
  • Canvas: Canvas is a heavy-duty cotton fabric that provides excellent durability and a rugged appearance. It is highly breathable, which helps prevent moisture buildup inside the bag, and is often used for bags designed for more extensive medical kits that may require additional protection for their contents.
  • Vinyl: Vinyl is a waterproof material that offers excellent protection against spills and moisture. This makes it suitable for first aid bags that may encounter wet environments, ensuring that the medical supplies inside remain dry and usable, thus enhancing the reliability of the kit in emergencies.
  • Medical-grade plastic: Some first aid bags feature compartments made from medical-grade plastic, which provides additional durability and protection. This material is usually easy to clean and can help keep contents organized, making it easier to find specific items quickly during a crisis.

What Are the Different Types of Empty First Aid Bags Available for Various Uses?

The different types of empty first aid bags available cater to various needs and situations.

  • Standard First Aid Bag: This type is designed for general use and typically includes compartments for storing various first aid supplies.
  • Outdoor First Aid Bag: Specifically made for outdoor activities, these bags are often waterproof and have additional space for larger items or specific gear like snake bite kits.
  • Sports First Aid Bag: Tailored for athletes and sporting events, these bags usually include quick access pockets for items like elastic bandages and cold packs.
  • Travel First Aid Kit: Compact and lightweight, this type is ideal for travelers and often includes essentials for minor injuries that can occur during trips.
  • Professional First Aid Bag: Designed for medical professionals, these bags are often larger and come with multiple compartments to organize a wide range of medical supplies and equipment.
  • Automobile First Aid Kit: Specifically made for vehicles, this kit is often compact and contains essential supplies needed for roadside emergencies.

Standard First Aid Bag: This type is designed for general use and typically includes compartments for storing various first aid supplies. They usually feature a sturdy zipper and may have reflective strips for visibility in emergencies, making them suitable for home or office use.

Outdoor First Aid Bag: Specifically made for outdoor activities, these bags are often waterproof and have additional space for larger items or specific gear like snake bite kits. Their rugged construction ensures durability against the elements, making them ideal for hiking, camping, or other outdoor adventures.

Sports First Aid Bag: Tailored for athletes and sporting events, these bags usually include quick access pockets for items like elastic bandages and cold packs. They are designed for rapid response to injuries during games or practices, ensuring that essential supplies are readily available.

Travel First Aid Kit: Compact and lightweight, this type is ideal for travelers and often includes essentials for minor injuries that can occur during trips. They are designed to fit easily into luggage or carry-ons, ensuring you have access to basic first aid supplies wherever you go.

Professional First Aid Bag: Designed for medical professionals, these bags are often larger and come with multiple compartments to organize a wide range of medical supplies and equipment. They typically feature high-quality materials and may include specific pockets for items like stethoscopes and bandage rolls.

Automobile First Aid Kit: Specifically made for vehicles, this kit is often compact and contains essential supplies needed for roadside emergencies. They usually come with reflective material for visibility and are designed to be easily accessible in case of an accident or breakdown.

Should You Choose a Backpack or a Pouch for Your Empty First Aid Bag?

Choosing between a backpack or a pouch for your empty first aid bag depends on your personal preferences and intended use. Both options have distinct advantages tailored to different needs.

Backpack:
Capacity: Generally offers more space, allowing you to store a more extensive array of supplies.
Portability: Easier to carry over long distances, making it ideal for hiking, camping, or road trips.
Organization: Often features multiple compartments and pockets, which can help you categorize supplies for quick access.
Comfort: Equipped with padded straps and supports, reducing strain during extended use.

Pouch:
Compactness: More lightweight and easily storable, perfect for everyday carry or for placing in a car glove compartment.
Accessibility: Designed for quick access; ideal for situations where you need to grab your supplies swiftly.
Versatility: Can be attached to belt loops or larger bags, providing convenience in various scenarios.
Specialization: Often designed for specific activities (like sports or travel), with tailored compartments for essential items.

Assess your needs thoroughly—whether for leisure, work, or emergencies—to determine which choice aligns best with your lifestyle and intended application.

What Brands Are Considered the Most Reliable for Empty First Aid Bags?

Some of the most reliable brands for empty first aid bags include:

  • Adventure Medical Kits: Known for their durable and well-organized first aid bags, Adventure Medical Kits offers a range of options that are perfect for outdoor adventures. Their bags often feature compartments that are specifically designed to hold various medical supplies securely, making it easy to find what you need in an emergency.
  • Ever Ready First Aid: This brand specializes in high-quality first aid supplies and bags at an affordable price. Their empty first aid bags are made from sturdy materials and come in various sizes, allowing users to customize their first aid kits based on personal needs or specific activities.
  • Surviveware: Surviveware is recognized for creating tactical first aid bags that are both functional and rugged. These bags generally come with a modular design and are constructed from water-resistant materials, making them suitable for a variety of environments, from hiking to camping.
  • Red Cross: The Red Cross brand is synonymous with emergency preparedness and first aid. Their empty first aid bags are designed with guidance from medical professionals, ensuring that they have the right layout and compartments to store essential supplies effectively.
  • Viva Medical: Viva Medical offers a selection of empty first aid bags that are perfect for personal use, home, or travel. Their bags are lightweight yet robust, featuring clear pockets for easy visibility of contents, which can be particularly helpful in a stressful situation.

How Can You Customize Your Empty First Aid Bag for Specific Needs?

Customizing your empty first aid bag involves selecting specific supplies tailored to your needs.

  • Adhesive Bandages: These are essential for covering small cuts and abrasions. Choose a variety of sizes to accommodate different wounds, and consider options with different materials, such as waterproof or hypoallergenic, based on your activities.
  • Antiseptic Wipes: These are crucial for cleaning wounds to prevent infection. Look for individually packaged wipes that are easy to use on the go, and ensure they contain effective antiseptic agents like alcohol or iodine.
  • Gauze Pads and Tape: For larger wounds, gauze pads can absorb blood and protect the injury while it heals. Pair them with medical tape to secure the pads in place, and consider including different sizes for various injuries.
  • Medical Gloves: Disposable gloves are vital for protecting both the caregiver and the injured person during treatment. Opt for nitrile gloves as they are less likely to cause allergic reactions compared to latex and provide excellent barrier protection.
  • Scissors and Tweezers: Scissors can be used for cutting tape, gauze, or clothing, while tweezers are helpful for removing splinters or foreign objects. Choose a compact pair of each that can be easily stored in your bag without taking up much space.
  • Pain Relievers: Including over-the-counter medication like ibuprofen or acetaminophen can help manage pain in case of injuries. Make sure to include dosage instructions and check for any allergies or contraindications if you’re packing for multiple people.
  • Emergency Blanket: A lightweight emergency blanket can provide warmth in case of shock or exposure to cold temperatures. These blankets are compact and can be a lifesaver in outdoor situations or emergencies.
  • First Aid Manual: Having a small first aid manual can be invaluable in a crisis. Look for a guide that covers basic first aid procedures, CPR, and how to handle specific emergencies, ensuring it’s easy to read and understand.
  • Allergy Medication: If you or others in your group have allergies, consider including antihistamines like Benadryl. This can be critical for managing allergic reactions, especially if you are in environments where allergens are present.
  • Instant Cold Packs: These are useful for reducing swelling or pain from injuries like sprains or strains. Choose packs that are easy to activate and can fit well in your bag without taking up too much space.

What Common Mistakes Should You Avoid When Choosing an Empty First Aid Bag?

When choosing the best empty first aid bag, avoiding common mistakes can ensure that you make a well-informed decision.

  • Ignoring Size and Capacity: It’s essential to select a bag that is appropriately sized for your needs. A bag that is too small may not accommodate all necessary supplies, while one that is too large could make it cumbersome to carry.
  • Neglecting Material Quality: The material of the first aid bag plays a critical role in its durability and functionality. Choosing a bag made from waterproof and tear-resistant materials will help protect your supplies from damage and extend the bag’s lifespan.
  • Overlooking Organizational Features: A well-organized bag enhances accessibility during emergencies. Look for bags with multiple compartments, pockets, and elastic loops to keep supplies neatly arranged and easy to find.
  • Failing to Consider Portability: The bag’s portability is crucial, especially if you need to carry it for long distances. Opt for a bag with comfortable handles and adjustable straps to ensure that it can be transported easily without straining.
  • Not Evaluating Closure Type: The closure type of the bag can significantly affect its usability. Zippers provide secure closure but can be cumbersome, while Velcro may be easier to open quickly; consider which type suits your intended use best.
  • Forgetting About Visibility: In emergencies, having a visible bag can save precious time. Choose a bag in bright colors or with reflective strips to ensure it can be easily spotted when needed.
  • Disregarding Personal Needs: Everyone’s first aid requirements can differ based on their specific activities or environments. Tailor your selection to include features that correspond to your lifestyle, such as pockets for specific medications or additional gear.
Related Post:

Leave a Comment